Showing posts with label adverse possession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label adverse possession. Show all posts

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Your adverse possession claim didn't die in your neighbors Estate.

For us property law geeks, the February 27,2015 Nimro v. Holden decision by the Maryland Court of Special Appeals is a fun and important decision. It marks a very important intersection between the law of adverse possession and the claim process in probate matters.



First, some background on the probate process:

  • When somebody dies an estate is created to administer all their "things."  This includes property rights, contract rights, ownership and debts.
  • The rules require that any claims against an estate must be made within a six-month limitation, or the claim is lost forever.
  • The six-month restriction on claims allows for the orderly and prompt administration of estates, and lets heirs inherit in a reasonable time.  Our country is built on the ability to efficiently move property and things from one generation to the next.
Next, some background on adverse possession:

  • It is a claim that takes ownership away from the title owner.
  • Among the requirements, the claimant must demonstrate adverse use for a 20 year period.
  • A court order must declare the transfer of ownership, if all the elements have been proven.
  • This involuntary transfer of ownership is meant to keep land in productive use.
This lawsuit highlighted an apparent gap in the law- what happens when someone dies, and an adverse possession claim has not yet been made against his land?  Is that claim lost if not raised in the probate proceedings within six months?

Mr. Nimro owned several lots overlooking the water. He claimed adverse use of the lots owned by the dead person's estate as an extended front yard that gave him unobstructed water views and beach access.  He did not make a claim in the estate, electing instead to sue in the Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County.

The Circuit Court judge sided with the estate, and ruled that the failure to make the adverse possession claim within the six-month limitation of the probate process extinguished the claim.  Mr. Nimro's claim was dismissed without a trial.

In this decision, the Maryland Court of Special Appeals got it right, and reversed the Circuit Court decision. In summary, the property rights created by the elements of an adverse possession action cannot be extinguished by the passing of the six-month probate limitation period (yes, that is a long sentence).

In the language of real property lawyers (and my inner property geek is now on full display), Maryland does not favor the creation of determinable and defeasible estates (fancy words that simply mean that an ownership interest can change based on future events). And to adopt the reasoning of the lower court would mean that a fully formed adverse possession claim would be subject to defeat if not brought prior to the death of the current legal title owner.  In essence, the court confirms what we practitioners have believed to be the better practice for years- an adverse possession claim need not be filed in a probate case.

This is consistent with other areas of established law, like the statute protecting mortgages and other recorded liens- a secured creditor does not lose a recorded lien if it doesn't file a probate claim within six months.

Well, that was fun. 

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

Extreme squatting comes to Maryland.

Last year we shared the story out of California involving lawyers complicit in a scheme to push false adverse possession cases through the courts. We concluded that such a scheme would be very difficult to pursue in Maryland because of very different standards for taking property under the law.

But that doesn't rule out the straight "squatter" who takes without permission.

On January 2, 2015, the Daily Record and an ABC News affiliate reported that a man was charged with moving into a home he did not own...with his entire family! He allegedly introduced himself to the neighbors, and was unpacking the van when the true owner arrived to find the invaders in the driveway.

Editor’s Note: This story was updated on Jan. 24, 2015, to remove the suspect’s name after the suspect contacted us to say the district court charges were dropped. We confirmed in the court's public database that the charges were subject to a "nolle prosqui." This means the prosecutor elected not to pursue the case, but it remains subject to re-indictment. Ramon Korionoff, public affairs officer for the Montgomery County State’s Attorney office, reported to other news outlets that the investigation is ongoing. The suspect also asserted to us that the video of the original television news story had been dropped from the television news affiliate's website, and he requested that we remove the embedded video from this blog.  It was only as a courtesy to him that we have removed the embedded video from this story. After all, we also represent criminal defendants and believe that everyone deserves a second chance! But we do not control, nor can we control that the video may remain resident and publicly available on the television news outlet's server.

The house had been on the market for over a year. The lesson behind the story is that you must check on your property regularly!! And talk to your neighbors--there is no reason for the alleged squatter to have fooled the neighbors, if that is what happened. It is easy to to knock on your neighbor's door to say "the house will be empty, call me if you see anyone try to enter."

In our real estate litigation practice, we've seen a lot of real estate scams (forged deeds, deeds executed after death, the impersonating of owners at settlement, producing fake death certificates, fake powers of attorney, and false corporate filings to reinvigorate defunct entities), but this story describes perhaps the most brazen and ill conceived that we have seen reported in the news.

Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Opportunity makes the thief.

On January 14, 2014, the California Attorney General filed criminal charges against two California lawyers and their clients for the alleged theft of 23 homes by use of forged documents and perjured court filings. The 144 page indictment outlines an elaborate scheme that relied on bogus adverse possession claims to induce the court system to award legal title to the defendants.

Can this happen in Maryland? It does.

Does it happen on the same scale? Perhaps. This office has only brushed the tip of the iceberg

In California, attorneys Craig Mortensen and Sheldon Feigel are alleged to have recruited members of the Barton family to pursue adverse possession claim in court in order to obtain court orders vesting members of the Barton family with legal title.

Adverse possession is a concept that is intended to keep land in productive use.  In a country built on the right to possess property, and to profit from that possession and the production of that property, the courts will make an involuntary transfer of ownership where a title owner is not acting like an appropriate steward.

Use it or lose it.



In California, the elements of adverse possession of a vacant home requires that the plaintiff actually use or rent out the property and pay property taxes for a minimum of five years. The criminal complaint alleges that these two basic requirements were not met, and that the lawyers and their clients submitted documents containing false affidavits and statements of fact to support these requirements.  The Attorney General alleges that the Barton family did not actually use or rent the properties for five years.

The scheme unraveled in 2010 when the true owner of a property contacted her lender and was told that title to the property had been recently changed to one of the defendants. A two year investigation by the Attorney General revealed a scheme that stripped lawful ownership of at least 23 properties.

Adverse possession in Maryland is much more difficult to demonstrate. For one, the use or occupation that is adverse to the true owner must be for 21 years. That alone is a huge impediment to fraudulent claims. Not many fraudsters are patient enough for such a long con.  Property fraudsters more often go for the quick flip.

We have seen title stripping fraud in a slightly different form than what is described in the Barton complaint. I call it "title squatting," and it requires a defunct limited liability company, the State of Maryland, and an unwitting title company.

In our case, the bad guy filed papers with the State of Maryland to reinvigorate a defunct limited liability company whose sole asset was Baltimore City house. The State of Maryland does not peer closely at the bona fides of a reinstatement application, as long as it recovers it's back taxes.

Once the defunct entity was reinvigorated, the bad guy found a title company that was duped into passing title from the entity to another entity that was legitimately owned by him. With title now rinsed through this transaction, the bad guy was empowered to sell the property to our client. And to keep the transaction as far as possible off anyone's radar, he took back owner financing.

All the while, the true owner of the defunct entity had no clue that his property had been taken from him.

It was the bad guy's threat of foreclosure that brought our client in out of the cold.  A careful examination of the title chain allowed us to quickly unravel the scam and obtain curative documents that properly restored title in the true owner's name. Fortunately, our client had title insurance to pay her losses-- she spent significant monies to fix up the property.

The title insurance company then sued the bad guy to recoup it's payment to our client. The complaint filed in court details the entire scam.

The lesson of both our Maryland case and the California indictments is simple:  Ownership has both privileges and responsibilities.  In exchange for the right to profit from ownership, you must remain engaged in the regular management of your property. Ignore your property at your peril-- a court might just take it away.